All articles

October 9, 2026 · 5 min

What Analytics Should You Ask a Creator for Before You Book Them?

A creator sends you a media kit with a follower count, a tidy engagement rate and three logos of brands they have worked with. None of that tells you whether a post for you will be seen by the right people, or seen at all.

Ask for five things before you book anyone: screenshots of reach or views on their last ten posts, the same for their last three sponsored posts, the audience country split, the audience age and gender split, and the follower growth chart for the past twelve months. Those five come straight out of the creator's own analytics tab, they take ten minutes to pull, and together they answer almost every question a media kit dodges.

Here is what to ask for, what each number is actually telling you, and what to do when a creator will not share them.

What is the minimum set of numbers to ask for?

Keep the request short and specific, and ask for images rather than typed figures.

  • Reach or views on the last ten posts in the format you are buying. If you are buying a Reel, the Reel numbers matter and the static post numbers do not.
  • Reach or views on the last three sponsored posts, with the brand visible.
  • Audience by country, top five.
  • Audience by age band and by gender.
  • Follower growth over the last twelve months.

If you are paying for a story, add taps forward, taps back and link clicks. If you are paying for a video, add average view duration or average watch time. Those are the numbers that tell you whether anyone stayed.

Why screenshots instead of a media kit?

A media kit is marketing material. It is made once, at the creator's best moment, and it reports whichever metric looked strongest that month.

A screenshot of the analytics tab is dated, shows the metric name the platform uses, and includes the posts the creator would rather you did not average in. You are not trying to catch anyone out. You are trying to see a normal week rather than a highlight.

Ask for the screenshots to be taken the day they send them, with the date range visible. A screenshot with no visible date range is not evidence of anything.

How should you read reach and views across ten posts?

Look at the shape, not the top number.

  • The median matters more than the best post. One video at ten times the usual number is not a forecast, it is an outlier.
  • The spread tells you risk. A creator whose posts land between 40,000 and 60,000 views is a safer buy than one who swings between 5,000 and 300,000, even if the second has a higher average.
  • The trend tells you timing. Numbers sliding down over six months means you are paying today for an audience that was there last year.
  • The format split tells you what to buy. Plenty of creators have strong video numbers and weak static numbers, or the reverse.

Then compare the sponsored posts to the organic ones. A drop of some size is normal and expected. A drop of eighty or ninety percent every time they post an ad tells you their audience tunes out branded content, and no amount of creative freedom fixes that quickly.

What does the audience breakdown actually tell you?

Two things, and both are about waste.

Country split tells you how much of the reach you can use. If you sell only in the United Kingdom and 70 percent of the audience is elsewhere, you are paying full price for roughly a third of the audience, and your cost per useful view is three times what the quote implies.

Age split tells you whether the content can do the job. If your product is for people over 35 and most of the audience is under 25, the post may perform beautifully and sell nothing.

Work out the cost per thousand against the audience you can actually sell to, rather than the whole audience. It reorders most shortlists.

What if a creator will not share their analytics?

Some reasons are fair. A creator early in their career may have thin numbers and feel embarrassed. A creator represented by a manager may need permission. A creator who has been burned by a brand collecting data and never booking anything will be cautious.

What to do, in order:

  1. Say why you are asking and what you will do with it. Most hesitation is about being compared, not about hiding something.
  2. Offer to take the numbers on a short call with screen sharing rather than by email, so nothing is stored.
  3. Reduce the ask to the two that matter most: reach on the last ten posts, and audience country split.
  4. If it is still a no, treat the booking as a paid test at a size you are happy to lose, and make the next booking conditional on the results you can see yourself.

A flat refusal with no explanation, on a large deal, from someone who is actively pitching you, is a signal in itself. Not proof of anything, but a reason to keep the first booking small.

How do you know the screenshots are real?

Two practical checks, neither of which needs a tool.

Compare what they sent against what you can see in public. Views on a public video and the comment count under it should sit in a believable relationship with the reach they claim.

Ask one specific question about an odd post. Anyone who pulled their own analytics can explain why one video went wide. Someone working from a doctored image usually cannot.

Beyond that, the only real verification is performance. A creator who delivered measurable results for another brand, and whose sales or signups can be traced, is a different proposition from one with a strong deck. That is the difference between a creator who looks right and a creator verified on real performance and conversion history.

The Bottom Line

Ask for reach on the last ten posts, reach on the last three sponsored posts, country split, age and gender split, and twelve month follower growth, as dated screenshots from the creator's own analytics. Read the median rather than the peak, discount the audience you cannot sell to, and keep a first booking small when a creator will not show you anything.

Doing that for every creator on a shortlist is slow, which is exactly why it is worth having someone do it before a name ever reaches your desk.