November 12, 2026 · 5 min
Should You Keep Booking Creators in January After the Holiday Push?
Your Q4 calendar is full, the creators are booked, and the budget is spoken for through the end of December. Then January arrives, sales slow down, and the easy decision is to pause everything until the new budget clears and someone decides what the year looks like. That pause is usually the most expensive thing you will do all quarter.
Keep something running in January, but change the job you are asking it to do. December content is bought to convert people who are already shopping. January content is bought to build consideration, to produce assets you will run as ads all year, and to hold onto the creators who just did well for you. A smaller always on slice, planned deliberately, beats both options most brands actually choose, which are stopping dead or repeating Q4 at half the budget.
Why does almost everyone stop in January?
Three reasons, and only one of them is a real reason.
The first is budget mechanics. New annual budgets often land late, and nobody wants to commit spend against a number that is not approved yet. That is real, and it is a planning problem rather than a marketing one.
The second is exhaustion. Q4 is a scramble. Trade press has reported creators saying brands push their holiday deals later and later each year, which means the people running the program are negotiating in November for posts that go live in December (Digiday on late holiday deals). By January nobody wants to open the spreadsheet.
The third is the assumption that nobody is buying. That one deserves a closer look, because it is usually wrong in a specific way.
What actually changes about results in January?
Demand does not vanish, it changes shape. Gift buying stops and self purchase starts. People who received your product in December are now using it, and people who nearly bought in December are still deciding.
Three things typically shift at once:
Conversion rates on creator traffic come back down from their December peak, because urgency is gone
Creator rates soften, because the brands who only run in Q4 have left the market and the calendar has room
Attention goes up on certain categories as resolutions kick in, which matters if you sell anything connected to health, home, organisation, learning or money
So your cost per view and your cost per booked creator tend to improve while your conversion rate drops. Whether that trade is good depends on what you are buying the content for.
How much should you keep running?
Think in terms of a floor rather than a campaign. The floor is the smallest amount of creator activity that keeps your program alive: enough posts that your brand keeps appearing, enough content that your ad account does not run dry, and enough contact that your best creators do not go and build a relationship with somebody else.
For most brands that floor is a fraction of December volume. If you ran twelve creators in December, three or four in January is a reasonable shape, with the budget skewed toward creators who already performed rather than new names.
The number matters less than the rule behind it. Never let the program go quiet for so long that restarting means starting from scratch with sourcing, outreach, briefing and contracting all over again.
Which creators should you keep working with?
Start with the ones whose December content actually earned its place: the posts that drove clicks and sales, not the ones with the biggest view counts. You already have the performance data, which is the one thing you never have when you book somebody new.
January is also the right month to test, because the cost of being wrong is lower. A creator you were unsure about is a cheaper experiment now than in October, and you will have the result in hand before the planning for the next peak starts.
What you should not do is go quiet with a creator who just delivered, then reappear in September asking for peak season availability. Creators remember which brands only show up when they need something.
What should January content actually say?
Change the angle before you change the budget. The December version of your message was about buying something in time. The January version is about using it, getting value from it, or solving the problem that got worse over the holidays.
Practical angles that tend to work:
Content that shows the product in ordinary use, now that the gifting frame is gone
Content aimed at people who received the product and are getting started with it
Content that answers the questions your December buyers asked your support team
Content built to be run as paid ads for the rest of the quarter, which means asking for usage rights up front and shooting in a way that works in a feed
How do you judge whether January worked?
Judge it against the job you gave it, not against December. If you bought consideration and content, then comparing January revenue to December revenue will tell you nothing except that December had a holiday in it.
Useful questions to ask at the end of the month:
Did we produce enough content to keep the ad account fed through the quarter?
Did our best creators from Q4 stay in the program and agree to the next booking?
Did cost per view and cost per click improve against December, and by how much?
Did anything we tested in January earn a bigger slot later in the year?
The Bottom Line
Do not treat January as off season. Treat it as the cheap month where you keep the program warm, bank content for the rest of the year, and hold onto the creators who just proved they work for you.
Scale down, change the angle, keep paying attention, and you start the year with a running program instead of a blank calendar and a sourcing problem.
Running a program at a steady floor through the quiet months is exactly the kind of work ViralFusion handles as an embedded part of a brand's team.